Review: These Broken Stars

-

These Broken Stars (Starbound, #1)Title: These Broken Stars
Author: Amie Kaufman
Genre: Science fiction, romance, young adult

My rating: 2.5 of 5 stars

Goodreads Summary:Luxury spaceliner Icarus suddenly plummets from hyperspace into the nearest planet. Lilac LaRoux and Tarver Merendsen survive – alone. Lilac is the daughter of the richest man in the universe. Tarver comes from nothing, a cynical war hero. Both journey across the eerie deserted terrain for help. Everything changes when they uncover the truth.
The Starbound Trilogy: Three worlds. Three love stories. One enemy. 




I'm not very impressed :/

I'll admit that when I first heard about this book, I was a little skeptical when I saw that flowing green dress on the cover. Flowing dresses on sci-fi book covers never ends well for me, but then I saw that almost everyone I knew who read this book ended up loving it, so I decided to give it a shot. Then there were alllll the reviews about how original this book was, how much science there was, how it was a survival story with a romance on the side instead of the other way around.

Well...

I think Emily May's review sums it up quite nicely: This is a romance novel, with a mysterious science fiction plot that only serves to progress their romance. There was hardly any worldbuilding, and most of the hazardous situations involved in the "survival on an alien planet" plot thread felt contrived (Oh, it's freezing, let's cuddle together for warmth because we're both beautiful people who don't have feelings for one another, nope!). I kept waiting for something actually terrifying to happen, or for the stakes to get raised, but they didn't until the very, very end and at that point I didn't care anymore.

Neither of the characters really captured my imagination or stole my heart. I couldn't care less about spoiled, selfish Lilac. Oh boo, you're the untouchable daughter of the richest man in the galaxy and all your friends are after your money and wealth, the horror. I did appreciate that she had some tricks up her sleeve (go women engineers!) but I just didn't like her. I didn't like Tarver either. His character was built around so many stereotypes and we were supposed to root for him despite his close-minded and stubborn attitude. I just couldn't get past the cardboard characters enough to care about what happened to them.

The "big stakes" reveal at the end was interesting, but I felt like the solution was too easy. There should have been way more consequences considering the nature of what they were dealing with. That just about sealed my opinion about this book: it's a romance novel pretending to be science fiction. Some people may really enjoy that, but that's the kind of book that's just not for me.

blog signature photo 4bf1c374-231a-40b6-8756-317f9308721c_zpsf45cae08.jpg
Follow on Bloglovin

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Insidious Side of the Golden Milk Latte

-
Image
Okay friends, strap in, this is going to be quite a rant about cultural appropriation and all the interactions that have been bothering me lately. I am just sick of hearing from my (predominantly white) friends how indignation at cultural appropriation is so "extra" and unnecessary, so here is my attempt to explain through my south Asian/desi lens exactly what I consider to be cultural appropriation and why it bugs me. Basically it boils down to this: If I get fun of for a certain part of my culture or heritage, but a white person can do the same thing and is applauded for being "boho chic", it's cultural appropriation. If a bunch of white people start profiting off of a part of my culture or start a "trend" without acknowledging the source, that's cultural appropriation too. Golden Milk Lattes This beverage has been making the rounds on all the health-focused hipster health blogs, and is essentially an up-cycled version of a tr
Read more

The Supremely Fabulous Fantasy Subgenre Flowchart

-
Image
Way back during Sci-Fi November , I made a flowchart of Science fiction subgenres so that everyone could find the sub-genre that they liked the most. The idea was that people could find recommendations in genres they didn't normally read, and maybe find a new favorite series or subgenre. It was way more popular than I imagined it would be, and a lot of you readers asked for a fantasy flowchart . Well, 6 months later, here it is! Again, some subgenres I made up and some are standard. I have read/watched most of these, but there are a few I haven't because I'm not familiar with every subgenre of fantasy. If you would like more suggestions in any of these genres, feel free to ask! I obviously couldn't fit all my suggestions on this tiny flowchart :) Fantasy Subgenre Flowchart You can always find the Sci-fi and Fantasy subgenre flowcharts by clicking on the SF/F Subgenre Flowcharts tab at the top of the page. Did you find a new subge
Read more

Way of Kings Readalong: Wrap-up

-
Image
So it's finally over. That was an amazing book! Thank you everyone for joining in and making my first readalong so much fun :) I have said over and over again that Brandon Sanderson is a storytelling god. This book makes me believe it even more fiercely - it takes a mastermind to create such intricate worlds and piece together so many character and plot threads. He does such a great job of feeding you just enough answers/revelations to keep you happy, but keeps you hanging by dangling all sorts of questions for you to answer. Not to mention the bombshells he throws in at the end... Having read Mistborn, I really should have been more prepared for disaster and mindblowing moments towards the end of the book. The end was just bombshell after bombshell - some were interesting revelations, and others were shattering. The bombshells of this week: 1) Navani proves that Dalinar's visions are real , and says his unconscious decoding of an ancient language will help pave the
Read more